Incoloy 901 Double End Stud

QS Fastener: Incoloy 901 Double End Stud

Name: Incoloy 901 Double End Stud
Material: Incoloy 901
Standard: UNS N09901
Size: M30
Length: 280 mm
Application: For Aeroengine Component
Feature: High Yield Strength and Durable Strength

Quantity

Contact Now

add to cart

Incoloy 901 Double End Stud (UNS N09901, M30×280mm) is specifically designed for critical components in aero engines. Manufactured from a high-performance iron-nickel-based superalloy, it offers exceptional yield strength and creep rupture strength, maintaining stable performance under extreme high-temperature and high-stress environments. It is an ideal choice for high-reliability connections in the aerospace sector.

Is the Incoloy 901 bolt equivalent to ASTM A453 Grade 660?
This is a highly specialized and important question concerning the material selection for high-temperature, high-strength fasteners, particularly when considering the use of a specific component such as the Incoloy 901 Double End Stud. The straightforward answer is: Incoloy 901 and A453 Gr.660 are NOT equivalent materials. They have significant differences in chemical composition, core properties, standard systems, and typical applications.

However, both belong to the category of high-performance, high-temperature, high-strength alloys and may serve as alternative options under certain operating conditions, but they must never be directly interchanged. For instance, a connection point designed for an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud cannot arbitrarily be replaced with an A286 material double-end stud.

A detailed comparison from several key dimensions is provided below to assist in making an accurate judgment during material selection:

1. Basic Identity and Standard Systems
Incoloy 901 (commonly used in manufacturing fasteners like the Incoloy 901 Double End Stud):
Type: A precipitation-hardening, wrought iron-nickel-chromium-based superalloy.

Standards: Typically follows material manufacturer specifications (e.g., Special Metals' UNS N09901) or AMS (Aerospace Material Specifications) standards, such as AMS 5660, AMS 5661. It is not a widely generic ASTM standard designation.

Key Feature: Strengthened by precipitation of the γ' phase through additions of aluminum and titanium, it exhibits excellent high-temperature strength and creep resistance in the 650-750°C range, which is precisely why the Incoloy 901 Double End Stud is suitable for extreme high-temperature environments.

ASTM A453 Gr.660 (Common Designation: A286):
Type: A precipitation-hardening iron-nickel-chromium-based stainless steel/superalloy.
Standards: It is a clear ASTM standard designation. The corresponding UNS number is S66286. It also exists in AMS standards (e.g., AMS 5731).
Key Feature: Also strengthened by the γ' phase, but its design is more balanced, offering good strength, toughness, corrosion resistance, and oxidation resistance at medium to high temperatures. It is one of the most widely used high-temperature, high-strength bolt materials.

2. Key Differences Comparison Table

Characteristic	Incoloy 901 (Typical, as in the Incoloy 901 Double End Stud)	ASTM A453 Gr.660 (A286)
Chemical Composition	High Nickel (~40%), High Iron, deliberately controlled high Ti/Al ratio to form a large volume of γ' phase.	More balanced Ni (~25%), Cr (~15%) content; Ti content lower than in 901.
Core Advantage	Extremely high high-temperature strength and creep resistance, especially above 650°C.	Excellent comprehensive performance: Good high-temperature strength (but lower than 901), better corrosion resistance, excellent low-temperature toughness, better machinability.
Maximum Service Temperature	Approx. 750°C (1380°F), focused on high-temperature strength.	Approx. 700°C (1300°F), focused on balanced performance.
Corrosion Resistance	Good oxidation resistance, but general corrosion resistance is moderate in certain media.	Superior to 901, due to its higher chromium content and composition closer to stainless steel.
Standards & Commonality	More common in specific high-temperature, high-stress aerospace and turbine engine applications, such as critical locations requiring an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud.	Extremely versatile, widely used for standard high-strength bolts in aviation, aerospace, petrochemical, nuclear power, and other fields.
Typical Strength Grade	Typically capable of achieving or exceeding a tensile strength grade of 160 ksi (1100 MPa).	Standard strength grades are 130 ksi (895 MPa) and 140 ksi (965 MPa).

3. Interchangeability or Substitutability?
The principle is: Absolutely DO NOT substitute directly on your own. Whether substitution is possible must be strictly evaluated and approved by a design engineer based on the specific operating conditions. If your project originally specifies an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud, exercise even greater caution regarding any material change.

If considering substituting A286 for 901 (e.g., replacing a design-specified Incoloy 901 Double End Stud):
Risk: At service temperatures approaching or above 700°C, the strength and creep resistance of A286 may be inadequate, potentially leading to bolt creep elongation, relaxation, or fracture, causing serious safety incidents.

Potentially viable scenario: When the operating temperature is below 650°C and higher corrosion resistance is required, A286 might be a more economical or suitable choice.

If considering substituting 901 for A286 (e.g., upgrading to an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud):
Risk: Cost is typically higher. At low or medium temperatures, its toughness may be inferior to A286. Corrosion resistance may be insufficient.
Potentially viable scenario: In environments with extremely high temperatures and stress, where the original A286 design might be approaching its performance limit, upgrading to an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud can enhance the safety margin.

Conclusion and Recommendations
1. Non-equivalent materials: Incoloy 901 (UNS N09901) and ASTM A453 Gr.660 (A286, UNS S66286) are two different alloys with no equivalence.

2. Core of material selection:
Choosing Incoloy 901 (for manufacturing components like the Incoloy 901 Double End Stud) is primarily to pursue maximum strength and creep resistance under extreme high temperatures.

Choosing A453 Gr.660 (A286) is to obtain balanced performance from low to high temperatures, good corrosion resistance, and excellent overall reliability.

3. Mandatory design principles to follow:
Strictly consult the original design drawings and technical specifications to clearly identify the specified material designation and standard.

Consult with a materials engineer or the design authority. Any material change (including using an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud to replace another material or vice versa) must undergo strict re-calculation and evaluation, considering all factors such as temperature, stress, environment, service life, etc.

Bolt materials are safety-critical components in pressure equipment. Unauthorized material substitution is strictly prohibited.

If you have specific information on the application scenario, temperature, stress, and environment, a further analysis can be conducted to determine which material (e.g., whether an Incoloy 901 Double End Stud is necessary) is more suitable, but the final decision rests with the design authority.

Send Message